Huawei loses landmark patent case at UK Supreme Courtroom


Huawei has misplaced a lawsuit over know-how licensing in a landmark Supreme Courtroom ruling that would flip London right into a hub for international patent litigation.

The UK’s highest courtroom dominated on Wednesday that the English courts have the ability to require telecoms firms and smartphone makers to take out a worldwide patents licence or face a UK courtroom injunction.

The choice has been hailed as one of the crucial vital mental property rulings in recent times as a result of it arms a bonus to patent holders and will result in steeper licensing prices for cell system makers corresponding to Apple and Samsung, in addition to Huawei.

Huawei introduced the long-running courtroom case in 2014 when it was accused of infringing mental property belonging to US firm Unwired Planet, which had acquired a clutch of patents overlaying wi-fi connectivity from Ericsson in 2013.

The Chinese language firm was ordered by the Excessive Courtroom in 2017 to pay a worldwide licence charge for infringing two UK patents in any other case it will face an injunction. Huawei appealed in opposition to the choice to the Supreme Courtroom, arguing that it ought to solely pay licence charges for the know-how within the UK, a comparatively small market, relatively than on its international gross sales. 

Lord Patrick Hodge, deputy president of the Supreme Courtroom, dismissed Huawei’s enchantment. Lord Hodge confirmed on Wednesday that the courts have the ability to grant an injunction to restrain infringement of a UK patent if an organization refused to take out a worldwide licence of a multinational patent portfolio.

Lord Hodge additionally dismissed an enchantment from Huawei and ZTE introduced in opposition to US group Conversant the place the 2 Chinese language firms had argued that the English courts weren’t the suitable discussion board to find out the validity of overseas patents.

The choice will pressure any tech firm that sells units within the UK to strike international offers with patent holders corresponding to Unwired Planet, which has a protracted historical past of litigation in opposition to the likes of Apple, Google and Samsung.

Yohan Liyanage, accomplice at Linklaters, mentioned extra litigation will observe. “There are already quite a few comparable circumstances pending within the UK and at present’s judgment will inevitably result in additional telecoms disputes being introduced within the UK,” he mentioned. Some system makers could even take into account withdrawing from the UK market altogether, as a way to keep away from being topic to international patent licensing charges, Mr Liyanage added.

The ruling comes as an additional blow to Huawei which is already beneath fireplace for its alleged hyperlinks to the Chinese language authorities and which was banned by the UK authorities from supplying new package for Britain’s 5G cell phone networks from subsequent 12 months on nationwide safety issues. It now faces getting into right into a licence with Unwired Planet in any other case it’ll face an injunction.

David Knight, accomplice at regulation agency Fieldfisher, mentioned the ruling might be a “remaining blow” to Huawei and its need to do enterprise within the UK.

The ruling that the English courts could make selections about worldwide licences has future implications for any firm utilizing important patents for 5G, notably with respect to the Web of Issues and related autos. 

Gary Moss, head of EIP Authorized, which represented Unwired Planet and Conversant within the lawsuit, mentioned the ruling can be intently watched. “The English courts are on the forefront of this space and it’s a really vital ruling,” he mentioned.

Unwired Planet welcomed the ruling. “We stay up for proceed working with different producers to supply licences to our patents beneath this international framework,” it mentioned.

Huawei didn’t instantly remark.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here