Fb and Google accused of complicity in Vietnam censorship


Amnesty Worldwide has accused Fb and Google of complicity in “industrial-scale repression” in Vietnam, underscoring the social media corporations’ awkward place in one in all Asia’s fastest-growing on-line markets. 

In a report revealed on Tuesday, the human rights group accused the businesses of being too amenable in complying with requests made by Vietnam’s communist authorities to take down content material.

Ming Yu Hah, Amnesty’s deputy regional director for campaigns, additionally stated that Fb and Google’s YouTube on-line platforms had change into “looking grounds for censors, navy troops, and state-sponsored trolls”. 

The allegations of abetting censorship in Vietnam adopted long-running accusations that Fb, which not too long ago launched an impartial oversight board, lent itself to manipulation by political campaigns or those that unfold hate speech in nations from the US to Myanmar and the Philippines. 

“Vietnam is the one nation we have now seen the place Fb has complied with such a level to a authorities’s extreme calls for,” Ms Hah advised the Monetary Instances. 

Vietnam, with a inhabitants of 97m, has 65m lively social media customers, with Fb and YouTube the 2 hottest social media platforms, in line with We Are Social, the consultancy.

Not like its communist neighbour China, Vietnam by no means banned the social media corporations. Fb, particularly, has performed a central function lately in permitting individuals to share data unreported on state-controlled media, and to organise protests. 

Nevertheless, in April Fb acknowledged that it had agreed to extend considerably its censorship of “anti-state” posts in Vietnam, saying that authorities had intentionally slowed site visitors to the platform to pile strain on it.

YouTube gained reward from Nguyen Manh Hung, Vietnam’s data minister, in October for its removing of what he described as “dangerous data propaganda towards the celebration and the state”. The official was quoted in state media as saying that Fb and Google had complied with 95 per cent and 90 per cent of its censorship requests respectively. 

“Fb supplies a free circulate of knowledge into a really repressive nation, and it’s the place individuals join with one another,” Lengthy Trinh, co-founder of Authorized Initiatives for Vietnam, a web-based journal centered on political and social points, advised the Monetary Instances.

“Nevertheless, I’ve modified my views of Fb during the last two years due to the way it co-operates with the Vietnamese authorities to restrict the circulate of knowledge.”

In keeping with Fb’s most up-to-date Transparency Report, the corporate restricted content material on the authorities’s request 834 occasions within the first half of this yr, up 985 per cent from 77 such incidents within the second half of 2019. 

“Fb was once a free place for political discussions, however now not,” Mr Lengthy stated. 

Fb stated it had been limiting content material after it grew to become clear that failing to take action would result in its providers being utterly shut down by Vietnamese authorities. “Over the previous few months, we’ve confronted further strain from the federal government of Vietnam to limit extra content material. Nevertheless, we’ll do every thing we are able to to make sure that our providers stay out there so individuals can proceed to precise themselves,” the corporate stated.

Google stated: “We depend on governments to inform us of content material that they consider is against the law via official processes, and can prohibit as applicable after an intensive assessment.” 

In keeping with Amnesty, there are 170 prisoners of conscience in Vietnam, the very best quantity the group has ever recorded. Two in 5 had been imprisoned, the group stated, for peaceable social media exercise. 

Twitter: @JohnReedwrites


  1. Hey, you used to write fantastic, but the last several posts have been kinda boringK I miss your great writings. Past several posts are just a little bit out of track! come on!


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here